← Heatmap / DeepSeek V4.1 Flash · Task 94
DeepSeek V4.1 Flash · Single-turn · Task 94 (Traps, conflicting pay (amount mismatch))
Mean 100.0%
| Field | Expected | Rollout #1 (100%) | Rollout #2 (100%) | Rollout #3 (100%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| decision | clarify | clarify | clarify | clarify |
| reason code | CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY | CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY | CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY | CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY |
| clauses | R7 R9 | R7 R9 | R7 R9 | R7 R9 |
Prompt
Process this monthly payroll record under the supplied rulebook. Return the R6 or R7 JSON answer.
Source documents: {"a63f2e3ab9c6eb39-payroll": {"kind": "payroll", "record": {"gross_pay": "4188.34", "payroll_month": "2026-04", "allowed_deduction": "161.97"}}, "a63f2e3ab9c6eb39-contract": {"kind": "contract", "gross_pay": "4163.34"}, "a63f2e3ab9c6eb39-amendment": {"kind": "amendment", "gross_pay": "4218.34", "effective_month": "2026-02", "approved": true}}
Authoritative case reference schedule: {"first-half": {"rate": "0.05", "cap": "4500.00", "deduction": "400.00", "free": "1100.00", "upper": "3300.00", "middle_rate": "0.12", "upper_rate": "0.24"}, "second-half": {"rate": "0.04", "cap": "3500.00", "deduction": "400.00", "free": "900.00", "upper": "3300.00", "middle_rate": "0.14", "upper_rate": "0.20"}}
Rollouts
Rollout #1 100.0% passed · 4.2s · $0.0011
| Component | Score | Clauses |
|---|---|---|
| decision | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| exact | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| field accuracy | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| citations | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| explanation | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
Assistant
{
"decision": "clarify",
"reason_code": "CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY",
"clauses": ["R7", "R9"],
"explanation": "The contract gross pay differs from the payroll gross pay, and the approved amendment does not match the payroll gross pay, so the conflict is unresolved. Please provide an approved amendment matching the payroll gross pay or reconcile the conflicting gross pay values."
}
Reasoning
We need answer JSON only. Need process. Need be careful. We have payroll record gross_pay 4188.34, month 2026-04, allowed_deduction 161.97. Contract gross_pay 4163.34 differs. Amendment gross_pay 4218.34, effective_month 2026-02, approved true. Need determine if conflict resolved under R9. R9: amendment resolves contract conflict only if approved, effective month <= payroll month, and its amount equals payroll record's gross_pay. It does not automatically change gross pay. Here approved true, effective 2026-02 <= 2026-04, amount 4218.34 equals payroll record gross_pay 4188.34? No, 4218.34 != 4188.34. So does not resolve conflict. Contract differs from gross_pay. Thus R7.4: return clarify CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY citing R7 and R9. Need no calculated monetary fields. Include explanation naming unresolved blocker and asking resolution. Allowed answer fields for clarify: decision, reason_code, clauses. Optional explanation. Need exactly those. No markdown. Ensure JSON object. Clauses maybe ["R7","R9"]. Explanation short. Need mention contract_gross_pay differs and amendment does not match gross_pay, so conflict unresolved. Ask provide approved amendment matching gross_pay or reconcile. Use no extra fields. Money not involved. Final.
Rollout #2 100.0% passed · 10.6s · $0.0013
| Component | Score | Clauses |
|---|---|---|
| decision | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| exact | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| field accuracy | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| citations | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| explanation | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
Assistant
{
"decision": "clarify",
"reason_code": "CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY",
"clauses": ["R7", "R9"],
"explanation": "The payroll gross pay is 4188.34, but the contract gross pay is 4163.34 and the approved amendment amount is 4218.34, which does not equal the payroll gross pay. The conflict remains unresolved; please provide an approved amendment matching the payroll gross pay or otherwise resolve the gross-pay source."
}
Reasoning
We need answer JSON only. Need process. Need carefully apply rules. Need determine if conflict? Payroll gross 4188.34. Contract gross 4163.34 differs. Amendment present: gross_pay 4218.34, effective_month 2026-02, approved true. It resolves conflict only if approved, effective <= payroll month (2026-04 yes), and its amount equals payroll record's gross pay. Amendment amount 4218.34 != payroll gross 4188.34. So does not resolve. Therefore optional contract_gross_pay present and differs from gross_pay, neither source precedence unless approved amendment resolves. Otherwise clarify CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY citing R7 and R9. Need return decision clarify, reason_code, clauses. Include short explanation naming unresolved blocker and asking resolution. No monetary fields. Need use exactly required answer fields for clarify: decision, reason_code, clauses. Optional explanation. So JSON:
{"decision":"clarify","reason_code":"CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY","clauses":["R7","R9"],"explanation":"The contract gross pay 4163.34 differs from payroll gross pay 4188.34, and the approved amendment amount 4218.34 does not equal the payroll gross pay, so it does not resolve the conflict. Please provide an approved amendment matching the payroll gross pay or resolve the gross pay source."}
Need ensure clauses only direct govern answer. R7 and R9. Maybe R1? For conflict cite R7 and R9 per R9. Good.
Need no markdown. Ensure money strings? Clarify no monetary fields. Explanation can mention money? It says money must be strings with two decimal places. If mention amounts, use strings? In explanation, numbers maybe "4163.34" not as field. But to be safe include with two decimals. Explanation is optional. It asks short explanation naming unresolved blocker and asking resolution. Good.
Need final only JSON.
Rollout #3 100.0% passed · 4.1s · $0.0008
| Component | Score | Clauses |
|---|---|---|
| decision | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| exact | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| field accuracy | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| citations | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
| explanation | 100.0% | R7 R9 |
Assistant
{
"decision": "clarify",
"reason_code": "CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY",
"clauses": ["R7", "R9"],
"explanation": "The contract gross pay 4163.34 conflicts with the payroll gross pay 4188.34, and the approved amendment amount 4218.34 does not equal the payroll gross pay, so it does not resolve the conflict. Please provide an approved amendment matching the payroll gross pay or confirm the correct gross pay."
}
Reasoning
We need answer JSON only. Need process. Need carefully apply rules. We have payroll record gross_pay 4188.34, month 2026-04, allowed_deduction 161.97. Contract gross_pay 4163.34 differs. Amendment gross_pay 4218.34, effective_month 2026-02, approved true. Need determine conflict resolution under R9. Contract conflict: optional contract_gross_pay present and differs from gross_pay. Need approved amendment resolves only if approved, effective <= payroll month, and amount equals payroll record's gross_pay. Here amendment amount 4218.34, payroll gross 4188.34. Not equal. Thus does not resolve conflict. Return clarify CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY citing R7 and R9. Do not calculate. Need include decision, reason_code, clauses, optional explanation naming unresolved blocker and asking resolution. Allowed fields for clarify: decision, reason_code, clauses. Optional explanation permitted. Need JSON object no markdown. Ensure exactly required answer fields and only clauses directly govern. For clarification include short explanation naming unresolved blocker and asking for its resolution. So {"decision":"clarify","reason_code":"CONFLICTING_GROSS_PAY","clauses":["R7","R9"],"explanation":"The contract gross pay 4163.34 conflicts with payroll gross pay 4188.34, and the approved amendment amount 4218.34 does not equal the payroll gross pay, so it does not resolve the conflict. Please provide an approved amendment matching the payroll gross pay or confirm the correct gross pay."}
Need check if any earlier missing? Gross present, month present, reference row for 2026-04 first-half exists in case schedule. Conflict present. Yes.
Need ensure no calculated monetary fields. Money strings? Not needed. Explanation maybe mentions money but not as fields. That's okay. Use only clauses R7 R9. Citation requirements? They said unresolved contract conflicts cite R7 and R9. Good.
Final only JSON.